9 Best Games Like The Quarry But For PlayStation 5
If you're searching for your next interactive horror adventure after playing The Quarry, you've come to the right place. This carefully curated list features the best narrative-driven horror games that deliver the same tension-filled experience you're craving. Each title offers games like The Quarry: branching storylines, choice-based gameplay, and cinematic storytelling that puts you in control of the characters' fates.
Whether you're drawn to teen slasher horror, psychological thrillers, or supernatural mysteries, these games excel at creating multiple endings based on your decisions. Expect quick-time events, moral dilemmas, and the constant fear that one wrong move could lead to a character's demise. From studio veterans to innovative newcomers, these story-rich experiences will keep you on the edge of your seat from start to finish.
Looking for something specific?
9 Games Like The Quarry But For PlayStation 5
1. Until Dawn
Until Dawn is the spiritual predecessor and closest match you'll find. Developed by Supermassive Games, the same studio behind The Quarry, this game pioneered the formula of teen horror with butterfly effect mechanics.
Set in an isolated mountain lodge, you control eight teenagers fighting to survive until sunrise. The game features the same cinematic camera angles, branching narrative system, and character relationship dynamics. Every decision matters through the innovative Butterfly Effect system, where small choices create rippling consequences.
Like The Quarry, it blends slasher movie tropes with supernatural horror elements, features a star-studded cast with motion capture performances, and offers incredible replayability with hundreds of potential outcomes. If you loved The Quarry, Until Dawn is absolutely essential.
2. The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope
The Dark Pictures: Little Hope comes from the same Supermassive Games formula but with a darker, more psychological approach. This installment focuses on a group stranded in a ghost town plagued by witch trial visions.
The game shares The Quarry's multi-character perspective, where you switch between different protagonists making life-or-death decisions. The QTE-based gameplay, hidden collectibles that reveal lore, and premonition system are all directly comparable.
What makes it particularly similar is the group dynamic under pressure and how relationships affect survival. It also features the same movie night mode for shared story experiences and delivers multiple endings based on your choices throughout the 4-5 hour campaign.
3. The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes
House of Ashes represents Supermassive's most ambitious Dark Pictures entry, trading supernatural horror for creature feature thrills. Set during the Iraq War, military operatives discover an ancient Sumerian temple filled with terrifying monsters.
This entry refined the formula with improved character models, more intense action sequences, and the same branching narrative structure. The constant threat of character death and relationship-dependent outcomes mirror The Quarry's tension.
The co-op modes (both online and local) let you share decision-making responsibility, and the game features the most action-oriented gameplay in the anthology while maintaining the cinematic storytelling approach. The death scenes are particularly brutal and memorable.
4. As Dusk Falls
As Dusk Falls takes a unique approach with its graphic novel art style, but don't let that fool you—this is a deeply engaging crime thriller about two families whose lives intersect during a hostage situation.
Like The Quarry, it features multiple playable characters, branching storylines spanning decades, and decisions that ripple through generations. The companion app multiplayer lets groups vote on choices together, similar to movie night mode.
The game emphasizes character relationships and consequences, with some of the most nuanced writing in interactive drama. While lacking horror elements, its tension-filled scenarios and exploration of trauma create comparable emotional investment in character survival.
5. Life is Strange: True Colors
Life is Strange: True Colors is the most polished entry in the franchise, featuring Alex Chen who can sense and manipulate emotions. Set in a small Colorado town, it blends supernatural mystery with coming-of-age drama.
Like The Quarry, it emphasizes character relationships, features branching storylines with multiple endings, and uses supernatural elements to enhance the narrative. The mystery investigation parallels The Quarry's clue-gathering system.
The game creates emotional investment through detailed character interactions, features stunning visuals and licensed music, and delivers choices that affect both story outcomes and character fates. The small-town setting and ensemble cast create similar community dynamics.
6. Still Wakes the Deep
Still Wakes the Deep is a first-person horror experience set on a 1970s oil rig in the North Sea. When something ancient and terrifying awakens, you must survive while the rig collapses around you.
While mechanically different (more exploration-focused), it shares The Quarry's isolated setting, small cast of characters fighting for survival, and atmospheric horror. The Scottish voice acting and character interactions create similar group dynamics.
The game delivers intense survival horror with breathtaking visuals, environmental storytelling, and the constant fear of death. The focus on regular people in extraordinary circumstances and creature-feature horror elements make it tonally similar.
7. Resident Evil Village
Resident Evil Village shifts from pure choice-driven narrative to survival horror action, but shares The Quarry's gothic horror atmosphere. Following Ethan Winters into a mysterious European village, it blends folklore horror with visceral combat.
The game features similar creature designs, isolated settings, and exploration of horror folklore. While gameplay differs (first-person shooter mechanics), the atmospheric storytelling and environmental horror create comparable dread.
Village excels at variety in horror—from werewolf attacks to psychological terror: similar to The Quarry's shifting threats. The mysterious village setting, ensemble of villains, and focus on survival against overwhelming odds hit similar thematic notes.
8. Alfred Hitchcock: Vertigo
Alfred Hitchcock - Vertigo is a narrative thriller inspired by the master of suspense, featuring a writer struggling with trauma after a car accident. The story jumps between three characters and timelines.
Like The Quarry, it features multiple perspectives, choice-driven storytelling, and a mystery that unfolds through character decisions. The psychological thriller elements and focus on unreliable narration create similar narrative intrigue.
The game emphasizes investigation and dialogue choices, features cinematic presentation, and delivers multiple endings based on your decisions. The French developer Pendulo Studios brings a unique European thriller aesthetic to the interactive drama genre.
9. Immortality
IMMORTALITY is Sam Barlow's most ambitious work, featuring actress Marissa Marcel who disappeared after three unreleased films. You explore footage from her movies to uncover what happened.
While abstractly different from The Quarry, it shares emphasis on player-driven discovery, multiple perspectives, and narrative mystery. The supernatural elements and focus on hidden truths create comparable intrigue.
The game features stunning performances, revolutionary match-cut navigation system, and a story that defies explanation without experiencing it. The blend of Hollywood pastiche and genuine horror creates a unique experience for fans of narrative experimentation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will there be a Quarry 2 game?
As of now, Supermassive Games has not officially announced a direct sequel to The Quarry. However, the studio continues to work on The Dark Pictures Anthology series, which shares similar gameplay mechanics and horror themes. Supermassive has expressed interest in returning to the format that made The Quarry and Until Dawn successful, so while a sequel isn't confirmed, it remains a possibility for the future. The studio tends to explore different horror subgenres with each project rather than creating direct sequels.
What type of game is The Quarry?
The Quarry is a cinematic interactive drama horror game with choice-driven gameplay. It combines elements of slasher films, supernatural horror, and teen drama into a playable movie experience. The gameplay revolves around making dialogue choices, exploring environments to find clues, and completing quick-time events (QTEs) during action sequences. It's designed to be replayed multiple times to discover different story branches and character outcomes, with decisions creating a butterfly effect throughout the narrative.
How many endings does The Quarry have?
The Quarry features 186 different endings, though this number accounts for various combinations of character survival, relationships, and story outcomes. The game has multiple major story branches that lead to significantly different conclusions, with numerous variations within those branches. All nine playable counselors can either survive or die based on your choices, and their fates combine with other narrative variables to create the total number of possible endings. This massive branching structure makes The Quarry highly replayable.
Is The Quarry a really scary game?
The Quarry delivers moderate horror that's more suspenseful than terrifying. It uses classic slasher movie tactics—jump scares, building tension, and gore—but isn't as psychologically disturbing as pure horror games like Silent Hill or Resident Evil. The fear comes from consequences: knowing your choices can kill beloved characters creates emotional dread. The game has adjustable difficulty settings, including options to skip QTEs or make deaths less frequent, so you can tailor the intensity. It's scary enough to create tension without being overwhelming for most players.
Can you play The Quarry with friends?
Yes! The Quarry features a Movie Night mode specifically designed for local co-op play. Up to eight players can participate, with each person assigned one of the nine counselor characters. When it's your character's turn to make decisions, you take control and pass the controller. This creates a shared experience where the group collectively determines the story's outcome. There's also an online co-op mode where you can play through the story with one other person, alternating control of characters. These multiplayer options make The Quarry perfect for game nights and group horror experiences.
How long does it take to complete The Quarry?
A single playthrough of The Quarry takes approximately 8-10 hours, depending on how thoroughly you explore and search for collectibles. However, the game is designed for multiple playthroughs—discovering all the different story paths, character outcomes, and endings can take 25-30 hours or more. Speed-running with minimal exploration might reduce a playthrough to 6-7 hours, while completionists hunting for all clues, tarot cards, and evidence will spend closer to 12 hours per playthrough. The chapter select feature allows you to replay specific sections to try different choices without starting completely over.
About the Author
Miguel (austernotus) is a game developer and pixel artist who believes the best recommendations come from understanding a game's core systems. With a background that spans from high-level MMO PVP (2100+ in WoW) to professional SEO, his analysis goes beyond the surface to find the games you'll actually love.